Transcript of the podcast:
Katy Milkman: Three Michelin stars. In the culinary world, it's the ultimate crown. Around 150 restaurants a year earn this distinction, a signal that the food is worth a special journey and a cut above the rest. It's a rating system French chef Marc Veyrat knows well. He earned three Michelin stars in 2018 for the adventurous food at his alpine restaurant La Maison des Bois. Think duckling roasted in pine bark. Soft-boiled egg infused with wild clover. Local lake fish in a coffee-and-toast glaze. All served in a chalet with dramatic views of Mont Blanc.
But less than a year later, the Michelin Guide revokes the accolade. La Maison des Bois saw its rating fall to two stars after a Michelin inspector gave an unfavorable review to one of its cheese soufflés. The critic claims there was cheddar in the soufflé, a basic English cheese not worthy of three stars. Veyrat claims he used local French cheeses, but added saffron, giving them a yellow color resembling cheddar. Furious, Veyrat sues the Michelin Guide and demands that his restaurant be removed from the publication altogether. He wants to be withdrawn from the forced rating system. The editors refuse, and a judge dismisses the lawsuit.
Today, Veyrat's daughter runs La Maison des Bois under a new name that in English translates to "my father's hamlet." As for Marc Veyrat, he opened a brand new restaurant. And if you walk up to the front door, you'll see a small sign that explicitly bans Michelin inspectors from entering. Now in his mid-70s, Veyrat has walked away from the endless pressure of being ranked, compared, and judged. In the hyper-competitive world of fine dining, he can now worry about one less measuring stick.
In this episode of Choiceology, we look at the surprising ways we react when we're measured against the people around us. I'm Dr. Katy Milkman, and this is Choiceology, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. It's a show about the psychology and economics behind our decisions. We bring you true and surprising stories about high-stakes choices. And then we examine how these stories connect to the latest research in behavioral science. We do it all to help you make better judgments and avoid costly mistakes.
It's 2006, and Fernando Alonso is the undisputed king of Formula 1. He's just won back-to-back World Drivers' Championships with the French racing team Renault.
F1 Announcer (Actor): Here comes Alonso around the final corner. He's going to take the checkered flag. He's—
Katy Milkman: He's at the absolute peak of his power. And for the upcoming 2007 season, the legendary McLaren team has managed to sign him.
Maurice Hamilton: It was a no-brainer that they were going to have the best car. And Alonso, with all his experience, was going to win that championship.
Katy Milkman: This is Maurice Hamilton. He's been an F1 journalist and broadcaster for nearly 50 years, and he's witnessed some of the most surprising moments in the sport's history, including McLaren's unforgettable 2007 season. He was there to watch McLaren pair their new superstar with an untested rookie, a driver making his debut at the highest level of motorsport.
Maurice Hamilton: Young chap called Lewis Hamilton, and this would be his first season in Formula 1.
Katy Milkman: Lewis Hamilton. No relation to Maurice. Today, he's one of the greatest drivers in F1 history with countless records, including most wins and podium finishes. But back then, he was just a promising kid out of the junior leagues. It was McLaren's legendary team principal Ron Dennis who saw his potential.
Maurice Hamilton: Ron Dennis had been watching Lewis Hamilton for quite some time. He'd watched him in the junior Formula. He'd seen that he was very talented, very promising indeed. And he was the ideal guy to have on board. He wasn't expected to do much in that season. He was expected to show a lot of promise, and he was expected to, if you like, justify McLaren's decision to have him alongside Fernando Alonso. Hamilton was clearly going to learn a lot.
Katy Milkman: Dennis had come up with a solid strategy. Pair the seasoned superstar with the eager rookie. He'd set up McLaren to have a good shot at beating team Ferrari, their fiercest rival in the team competition. And the plan would also set Alonso up to secure his third consecutive individual title.
Maurice Hamilton: And that all made a lot of sense, but didn't quite work out that way.
Katy Milkman: The 2007 season kicked off with the Australian Grand Prix.
Maurice Hamilton: It was very exciting actually because the first race was in Melbourne. Great atmosphere, great crowd there, good circuit. They had a meet-the-press thing on a nearby beach on the Thursday before, and all was sweetness and light. It was lovely. The sun was shining. The sea was blue. The two drivers were there. They were getting on well together. It all looked a happy scene. In the background, those of us who are perhaps looking for more of a punchy story were hoping that maybe Lewis is going to give Fernando a hard time.
Katy Milkman: Maurice and the rest of the media didn't have to wait long.
Maurice Hamilton: It was the start of the first race in Melbourne. Lewis was behind Fernando and the grid. They were near the front. And for sure, the McLaren boss, Ron Dennis, will have said to Lewis Hamilton, "Now listen, it's the first race of a long season. You've got a lot to learn. No heroics. Don't do anything daft. Just stay calm. Stay cool. We want you to finish the race." And that's what we all expected to happen, that he would behave himself, tuck in behind Fernando Alonso, follow the former champion, and see how it's done.
And the race starts, and the first corner is a tight right-hander followed by a left-hander almost immediately. Not far from the start line. So you can imagine the first corner, of course, is always chaotic. It's the closest the cars will ever be physically. So it's a moment to take your chance and try and get past somebody else. So they go rushing into the first corner side by side and blow me down, Lewis Hamilton runs around the outside of Fernando Alonso and gets ahead of him. And you thought, "What is Fernando Alonso going to make of this?"
Katy Milkman: By the end of the 58 laps, Alonso's experience ultimately won the day. He managed to claw his way back ahead to finish second. Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen took first place. And in third, astonishingly, the rookie.
Maurice Hamilton: There he was on the podium for his first Grand Prix, and that was laying down a marker. The first corner, getting around the outside of Fernando Alonso, finish on the podium, and we suddenly thought, "Ooh, this is going to be a little bit different than perhaps we thought."
Katy Milkman: In professional racing, drivers rarely show their hand. They don't want to admit when someone gets under their skin. So while it was all smiles for the cameras, behind closed doors, that opening race sowed the seeds of a season-long rivalry.
Maurice Hamilton: McLaren now have the start of a problem here because Lewis Hamilton is making a bid, and he's got every right to say, "I'm accumulating the points. I'm on my way to winning the championship or having a go at it. It's not all about Fernando Alonso."
Katy Milkman: The season wasn't shaping up to be a rivalry between team Ferrari and team McLaren. It was teammates Hamilton versus Alonso.
Archival Announcer: And Alonso is off again in Montreal. He's gone straight through the grass at turn one for the fourth time today. He is fighting the car. Lewis Hamilton continues to lead the Canadian Grand Prix.
Katy Milkman: As the season progressed, Hamilton's race results continued to surprise and impress. Hamilton took home a win at the Canadian and American Grand Prix. And suddenly the rookie wasn't just keeping up with the world champion. He was leaving him behind.
Maurice Hamilton: At that point, definitely Ron Dennis, the boss of McLaren, would've been approached by Alonso to say, "Look, you're supposed to be backing me up here. He's winning races. OK. He's doing it because of the way the races fell, but I think I need a lot of support here." So that was adding to the pressure as the season went on.
Katy Milkman: Any early-season harmony was long gone. In its place, a tense and fractured McLaren garage, with two drivers going for the same crown and entirely focused on one scoreboard, each other.
Maurice Hamilton: When they had a press conference together, you could sense there was a certain frisson between them. They weren't pals. They weren't great mates. They were sociable. They would show that they were teammates. There was no "I'm not speaking to you," none of that. But there was a definite edge, shall we say, compared to when we'd seen them all pals at the first race of the season in Melbourne.
Katy Milkman: The rivalry finally boiled over at the Hungarian Grand Prix. With only six races left in the season, Hamilton was leading Alonso by a mere two points.
Maurice Hamilton: So that is not much, but he's ahead. And that is not what Fernando Alonso would've expected. Alonso will definitely be wanting to lay down a marker and get established and win more Grand Prix. Stop Lewis Hamilton from building up that lead that he has.
Katy Milkman: At this tight twisting track, overtaking is almost impossible. It all comes down to pole position, the coveted number one spot at the very front of the starting grid. Whoever secures that clean, open road on Saturday's qualifiers almost always wins the race on Sunday.
Maurice Hamilton: It so happened that Fernando Alonso was to have the advantage of this particular race, but Lewis Hamilton during qualifying blocked him and got in the way. He said it wasn't intentional, but it was a problem for Fernando Alonso.
Katy Milkman: Hamilton had allegedly ignored team orders and blocked Alonso early on. Alonso was furious. And right before the final lap of qualifiers, he took his revenge.
Maurice Hamilton: They have to make a pit stop and take on a little bit more fuel, change tires, and go out again for the final qualifying lap. And that was supposed to be then Lewis Hamilton's turn to put in a quick lap. And Alonso held him up in the pit lane, stopped him.
Archival Announcer: There's Lewis Hamilton queuing up behind him. Is he blocking Hamilton there?
Katy Milkman: A standard pit stop takes less than four seconds. But after his tires were changed, Alonso sat stationary for five, 10, 15, 20 agonizing seconds, just staring ahead. Hamilton was trapped directly behind him, watching the clock tick down.
Maurice Hamilton: You could see it. It was deliberate. To the point where Ron Dennis, when it happened, ripped his headset off and threw it down on the pit wall. So clearly all was not well in McLaren.
Katy Milkman: By the time Alonso finally sped away, it was too late. Hamilton didn't have enough time to complete a final qualifying lap. Alonso had successfully sabotaged his own teammate, securing pole position for himself.
Maurice Hamilton: The whole thing broke into chaos, and the gloves were off. It was every man for himself.
Katy Milkman: F1 officials launched an immediate investigation into the pit lane holdup. Just past midnight, the verdict came down. Alonso was hit with a five-place grid penalty for unnecessarily impeding his teammate. Alonso was dropped to sixth. Hamilton was promoted to pole and won the race.
Maurice Hamilton: He led every lap, and Alonso had to fight his way through and finished third.
Katy Milkman: The timing couldn't have been worse for McLaren because behind the scenes, the team was also facing an existential crisis. It's a scandal known in F1 history as Spygate. Members of the McLaren team had been sent hundreds of pages of Ferrari documents detailing car design and engineering. The sports governing body launched a massive inquiry. It wouldn't just cloud the rest of the season. It would ultimately land McLaren with a staggering $100 million fine. So with a massive legal war hanging over their heads, they also had this internal warfare between their drivers to navigate.
Maurice Hamilton: What was actually happening from a driver's point of view, from the psychology of it all, was that it was affecting Alonso more than it was affecting Hamilton. Lewis Hamilton, meanwhile, was just getting on with driving. And the team were trying to now pacify a clearly upset Fernando Alonso because this was not going his way. His view was that he should be winning the championship. And here in his eyes, McLaren are trying to facilitate Lewis Hamilton and trying to help him win. Not necessarily true. It was just the way it played out. But Alonso was taking it pretty badly.
Katy Milkman: Alonso began making mistakes on the track that were uncharacteristic of the world champion. In Japan, under immense pressure and a heavy downpour, he crashed out entirely, scoring zero points.
Maurice Hamilton: That rare error by Fernando Alonso was because he was getting himself worked up by what was going on. He was allowing it to affect him too much.
Katy Milkman: And in China, with Hamilton on pole, Alonso continued to let his frustration show. He struggled to get onto the second row of the grid.
Maurice Hamilton: And he was very, very unhappy about it to the point where he had an argument with the team, with his engineers. He went back into the office behind the pits, and he punched up his fists through the door. He was so angry. So that really gave you some indication of how he was allowing emotion to affect his driving.
Katy Milkman: Finally, the last race of the season arrived in Brazil. Because the two McLaren teammates had spent the entire year taking points off of each other and actively tearing their own team apart, they'd left the door wide open for their rival at Ferrari, Kimi Raikkonen, to gain a foothold.
Maurice Hamilton: We had a Ferrari on pole position, and we had Lewis Hamilton on the outside of the front row. And Fernando Alonso was directly behind Lewis in the second row.
Katy Milkman: On race day, everything went wrong for McLaren. Hamilton suffered a mechanical gearbox glitch that dropped him to seventh. Alonso couldn't match the pace and finished a distant third. And when the checkered flag fell, the impossible happened.
Maurice Hamilton: Kimi Raikkonen won the Drivers' Championship by one point. Fernando Alonso and Lewis Hamilton were tied on 109 points. Kimi Raikkonen scored 110. Fernando Alonso should have won that championship. He should have scored more points than Raikkonen if he had been totally focused on winning races and not allowing himself to be upset by what he thought was going on.
Katy Milkman: It was a devastating end to a tumultuous 2007 season for Team McLaren. They had the fastest car, the best-experienced driver, and the most-talented-in-a-generation rookie. And they walked away with absolutely nothing. In trying so hard to beat each other, the two teammates had lost sight of the bigger picture. Their obsession with winning an internal team battle cost them the entire championship.
Maurice Hamilton: If you are going to have the superstar and the young guy, the young guy's got to be cool. He's got to not allow the pressure to get to him. He's got to allow the fact that the superstar driver will be quicker. And so he's got to work out that he's actually going to get there and catch up with him in the end through experience. But what was different about '07 was that Lewis Hamilton was quick straight away, which was very, very rare. Very, very rare. So yeah, it was a truly memorable year. I just will never forget it.
Katy Milkman: Lewis Hamilton would recover, winning his first world title the next year with McLaren. He's since gone on to build one of the most dominant dynasties the sport has ever seen. But for Alonso, 2007 was a turning point. Furious after a disastrous season, he walked away from McLaren. It was a bitter exit from a powerhouse team that should have brought him great success. In trying so hard to defeat a rookie teammate, the reigning king had inadvertently altered the course of his entire legacy.
Maurice Hamilton is a Formula 1 journalist, broadcaster, and author. You can learn more about his work in our show notes or at schwab.com/Choiceology.
There are dozens of famous team rivalries in sports history. The Lakers versus the Celtics, or the Yankees versus the Red Sox. But things get exponentially more complicated when a bitter rivalry is happening within a team. When teammates become rivals, it introduces a toxic dynamic that can completely jeopardize both individual and team success. And that's especially true when a rigid ranking system forces players to monitor exactly where they stand relative to the person sitting right next to them.
My guest today studies how intensely competitive environments with individual rankings can provoke counterproductive social comparisons that distort our emotions and our performance. Nir Halevy is a professor of organizational behavior at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business. He's also the author of the new book Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them.
Nir, thank you so much for joining me today. I'm thrilled to have you.
Nir Halevy: Thank you, Katy. It's great to be here.
Katy Milkman: I want to kick off with a definition if we can. I would love it if you could define what it means to engage in social comparison and maybe give an example or two of situations where it's really common for us to make social comparisons.
Nir Halevy: We engage in social comparisons when we compare ourselves to other people and use them as the standard to evaluate how well we're doing. We can think about wealth as an example. So when you use a friend, a colleague, a sibling as the standard of comparison to figure out how well you're doing financially, that would be engaging in a social comparison. Let's say that you're uncertain about whether you saved enough for retirement or not. You could compare yourself to your past performance. Did you save this year more than you did last year? You could compare yourself, your performance to your goals. Are you falling short of your saving goals? Are you exceeding your saving goals? And you could compare yourself to other people. The last option would be social comparison.
Katy Milkman: Yeah. And I know I unfortunately do it more than I would like because it doesn't always make me happy, but we're doing it constantly as academics. How many papers have I published this year versus how many Nir has published? I was hoping you could also talk a little bit about the difference between upward and downward social comparisons and how both affect us.
Nir Halevy: Definitely. We have a choice. We can choose to compare ourselves to people who are better off or worse off relative to us. We can think about the context of social media and body image, for example. When we think about our teenagers and how they compare themselves to high standards of body image they see on social media, we have a sense that that makes them feel inadequate or worse about their own bodies and their own image. So the choice we have to compare upward or downward shapes how we feel subsequently.
Katy Milkman: Nir, I know there's some really interesting work on the rate at which we tend to engage in upward versus downward social comparisons. Could you talk a little bit about what that work shows?
Nir Halevy: So we tend to compare ourselves mostly upward rather than downward. And that's partly because we want to feel that we belong in a category with other high-achieving individuals, high-performing individuals. And so we tend to gravitate in terms of our attention allocation to people who are high performers, high achievers, successful people. In one of our decision-making experiments, we gave people either $1 or $5, and this was common knowledge. Everyone saw that some people in the room received $1, and other people in the room received $5. And then we had them engage in a decision-making task where they could decide how to allocate the resources we made available to them.
People who received $1 were more likely, significantly more likely, to allocate their resources in a way that harmed those who received $5, to take away their resources, to pull them down because of that experience of relative deprivation. So we know that the tendency to compare upward makes us feel worse about our performance, about our achievements, about our ability, and it can also undermine cooperation and even increase sabotage.
Katy Milkman: So why is it that when this makes us feel worse, and when we have a choice, we are making these upward social comparisons more than downward social comparisons? What's going on?
Nir Halevy: There are multiple answers. The first answer is that we feel before we engage in this comparison that we will actually be very similar to them. We think that we will assimilate into that category, that we will judge ourselves as performing well. The second answer to this is that there's an effect called better-than-average effect. We think that we tend to be better on a range of tasks, whether it's our driving ability or our kindness to other people, more than the average person. And so that reinforces our expectation that when we compare ourselves to high standards, we will feel very close to them. We will see ourselves as similar to them. We will assimilate to that category of successful individuals. And the third explanation is that we often are making predictions are inadequate or miscalibrated in terms of affective forecasting. We think that we will feel a certain way, but we get it wrong often.
So when we choose our standards for comparison, we might engage in upward social comparisons, not realizing because of this affective forecasting error that we will feel worse after we make this comparison. And so when you put together these different processes, we tend to often choose to engage in upward social comparisons.
Katy Milkman: Nir, you've done some really interesting research on how the type of hierarchy we find ourselves in affects both our likelihood of engaging in social comparisons and also how effectively we collaborate. So to start, I was hoping you could actually explain what a company with a ladder type of hierarchy would look like, and also what a company with a pyramidal-type of hierarchy would look like, because these are two distinct forms of hierarchy you've written about, and I don't think the names are necessarily going to be intuitive to listeners. So I think having a sense of what those structures look like will really help as we walk through some of this work.
Nir Halevy: Definitely. So ladder-shaped hierarchies have rank-ordered individuals in occupying different positions. You can think about ATP rankings in tennis, for example. So you have players, and it's common knowledge who occupies which rank. And it's very rare for different tennis players to occupy the same rank in the ATP rankings. In contrast, we can think about pyramidal shapes for hierarchies. And in the context of pyramids, I would like to think about centralization rather than stratification. So centralization means that a lot of power, a lot of decision-making authority, a lot of control is concentrated in the hands of very few decision-makers. And so you can think about a CEO or a team of top management making a lot of decisions on how to allocate resources, budgets, personnel, and so on. So ladder-shaped hierarchies are very stratified, whereas pyramid-shaped hierarchies tend to be very centralized in terms of who controls the resources.
Katy Milkman: How does it change people's likelihood of engaging in social comparisons and how successfully they collaborate if they're in one of these ladder-type organizations where everyone is ranked versus one of these pyramidal organizations where there are people at the top and bottom, but a lot of people are grouped together in the same level of the hierarchy?
Nir Halevy: So when we studied financial services firms in the Netherlands, we discovered that the more you feel that your team, your organizational hierarchy, is shaped like a ladder, the more likely you are to engage in those social comparisons. You're monitoring the environment, comparing how you're doing relative to other people on your team. And that hurts collaboration, that harms performance at the team level. We then took this finding to the lab and we created three-person teams. We randomly assigned the teams in lab to one of two conditions. In one condition, their hierarchy took the shape of a ladder. That is, we had one person at the top, one person in the middle, one person at the bottom. In the pyramidal condition, we had one person at the top and two people were occupying the same lower position relative to that high-ranking person.
We also reinforced that manipulation of structural hierarchy in terms of the compensation structure within these teams. And we saw the same effect that we saw in the field where the ladder-shaped hierarchies collaborated less. They were less successful in solving the logic puzzle that was an objectively scored task that we gave them in the lab context. And so all of these harmful effects on social relations within a team and the harmful downstream consequences for team performance were observed in the field and in the lab.
Katy Milkman: I was wondering if you could also talk about situations where clear ranked hierarchies can be helpful to collaboration because I know that it can sometimes be useful. And I'm thinking of your work on teams in the National Basketball Association where sometimes knowing exactly who the top dog is really helps the team win. And the contrast between what you find there and what's been found in Major League Baseball, where big pay disparities between players seem like they can cause real tension.
Nir Halevy: In our own research in professional basketball, we discovered that when you have a larger pay dispersion in terms of people's players' salaries, when you allocate positions in the starting lineup more hierarchically, when you allocate playing time on the court more hierarchically, teams win more games in a season. And the reason they win more games in a season is because you have better coordination and collaboration. You have more assists, you have fewer turnovers. Those measurable behaviors that actually tell you that the coordination and cooperation within the team works better.
Now there is a really important difference between baseball and basketball. Let's think about offense. In baseball, offense is played sequentially. You go to bat alone, you take turns. You don't support other people on offense when you're playing baseball. Basketball is very, very different. You set screens for other people. You help them get better shots. You pass the ball to them. You provide them with assists. So the fact that you're simultaneously performing on offense in basketball is meaningfully different than baseball, and it makes the hierarchy more justified, more instrumental, more functional relative to baseball.
Katy Milkman: OK. So in other words, even though a hierarchy can lead me to perhaps be jealous or anxious or engaging in social comparisons, and we've even talked about sometimes undermining other people, if it's functional because it clarifies our roles, it can be helpful in certain circumstances. So there's a lot of subtlety here, right? Is that the right way to think about this? If the hierarchy is meritocratic and delineates who has responsibility for what or who ultimately is the leader, then this kind of hierarchy and ranking can be useful.
Nir Halevy: Definitely. So one of the benefits of hierarchy is that it clarifies roles, responsibilities. So meta-analytic findings show that in situations characterized by high levels of ambiguity, that's when we're going to see the benefits of hierarchy. We want to distinguish in roles and ranks when it's legitimate, when it's functional, when we're seeing the benefits in terms of coordination, collaboration, team performance. And if we're not seeing those benefits, we should really change how we're doing hierarchy. So let's choose two examples, one where we're not seeing a lot of interdependence, there is no team context, and one where there is. So if we go to the first context, let's think about social media and people monitoring how many followers they have relative to other people or how many likes they got on a social media post. There is no interdependence there. They're not trying to coordinate, collaborate, perform together.
So we can think that upward social comparisons in this particular context might be deflating and harmful and make people feel worse about their performance as people trying to get an audience on social media. But if we think about the context of academia, we can think about a team with a postdoctoral fellow, with a graduate student, with an undergraduate student. And it can be really helpful for the undergraduate student to look up to a graduate student who's accomplished and successful and has mastered certain skills that they have yet to master and learn from them.
Katy Milkman: Wonderful. And super intuitive, but I think often people aren't recognizing all of these different functions that these comparisons have, that we do this social comparison in context where it is functional and where it's dysfunctional.
Nir Halevy: Yes.
Katy Milkman: So on that note, what advice do you have for our listeners on how they can make better decisions now that they know more about your research on social comparisons and hierarchies?
Nir Halevy: I encourage everyone to use multiple reference points when they try to evaluate how well they're doing. And if you go back to our opening example of wealth or how well you're doing financially, think about how you did last year. Are you doing better this year? Think about your goals for the future. What are you going to change in order to be better at saving for retirement next year? So those are useful reference points. I encourage people to use multiple reference points when they evaluate themselves.
Katy Milkman: That is great closing advice. I really appreciate you spending time with us today, Nir. Thank you so much for talking to me, and thanks for the incredibly interesting research you do.
Nir Halevy: Thank you, Katy. It was great talking to you.
Katy Milkman: Nir Halevy is a professor of organizational behavior at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business, and he's the author of the new book Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them. You can find links to his research and book in the show notes and at schwab.com/choiceology.
When it comes to investing, what matters most isn't how your portfolio stacks up against others. It's whether it's positioned to help you reach your own financial goals. For more on aligning your portfolio with those goals, listen to the Financial Decoder episode entitled "How Should Your Goals Shape Your Portfolio?" at schwab.com/FinancialDecoder or in your favorite podcast app.
Marc Veyrat, the chef who came to hate Michelin stars, and Fernando Alonso, the Formula 1 champion, had very different careers, but they both found misery and social comparisons at the very top of their games, in moments when they had every reason to feel nothing but pride. As Nir explained, it's human nature to make upward social comparisons, whether we're sizing up our investment portfolio, our online following, or our salary against someone else's. The solution isn't to stop comparing ourselves to other people altogether, but it can be more productive to track your own progress against your own past performance and your own goals and save the upward social comparisons for the moments when there's actually something to learn from the people outperforming you.
That's all for this episode of Choiceology, an original podcast from Charles Schwab. For more insights on how to improve your decisions and reach your goals, grab a copy of my book, How to Change, or sign up for my newsletter, Milkman Delivers, on Substack. If you got value out of today's episode, we'd be so grateful if you could drop us a quick review on Apple Podcasts or a rating on Spotify. It helps the show grow and connects us with new listeners. I'm Dr. Katy Milkman. Talk to you soon.
Announcer: For important disclosures, see the show notes or visit schwab.com/choiceology.
After you listen:
When it comes to investing, what matters most isn't how your portfolio stacks up against others. It's whether it's positioned to help you reach your own financial goals.
- For more on aligning your portfolio with those goals, listen to the Financial Decoder episode entitled "How Should Your Goals Shape Your Portfolio" in your favorite podcast app.
When it comes to investing, what matters most isn't how your portfolio stacks up against others. It's whether it's positioned to help you reach your own financial goals.
- For more on aligning your portfolio with those goals, listen to the Financial Decoder episode entitled "How Should Your Goals Shape Your Portfolio" in your favorite podcast app.
When it comes to investing, what matters most isn't how your portfolio stacks up against others. It's whether it's positioned to help you reach your own financial goals.
- For more on aligning your portfolio with those goals, listen to the Financial Decoder episode entitled "How Should Your Goals Shape Your Portfolio" in your favorite podcast app.
When it comes to investing, what matters most isn't how your portfolio stacks up against others. It's whether it's positioned to help you reach your own financial goals.
- For more on aligning your portfolio with those goals, listen to the Financial Decoder episode entitled "How Should Your Goals Shape Your Portfolio" in your favorite podcast app.
There are plenty of legendary team rivalries in sports—the Lakers versus the Celtics, or the Yankees versus the Red Sox. But things get far more complicated when that bitter rivalry happens inside the team itself.
In this episode of Choiceology with Katy Milkman, we explore what happens when we compare ourselves to our peers in highly competitive, ranked environments—and how social comparisons can distort both our performance and our happiness.
Veteran Formula 1 journalist Maurice Hamilton shares the unforgettable story of McLaren's 2007 season, where a dream-team pairing between champion Fernando Alonso and rookie prodigy Lewis Hamilton devolved into a championship-costing war. Maurice has authored over 30 motorsport books, including the Racing Legends series for young readers and Formula 1 Cars: The Greatest F1 Cars From 1950 to the Present Day.
Then, Katy speaks with Stanford Organizational Behavior Professor Nir Halevy, author of the new book Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them. They discuss why humans naturally compare themselves upward, how rigid "ladder-shaped" hierarchies trigger workplace sabotage, and how to use personal baselines to escape the comparison trap.
Choiceology is an original podcast from Charles Schwab.
If you enjoy the show, please leave a rating or review on Apple Podcasts.
This material is intended for general informational and educational purposes only. This should not be considered an individualized recommendation or personalized investment advice.
The comments, views, and opinions expressed in the presentation are those of the speakers and do not necessarily represent the views of Charles Schwab.
Data contained herein from third party providers is obtained from what are considered reliable sources. However, its accuracy, completeness or reliability cannot be guaranteed.
All corporate names and market data shown above are for illustrative purposes only and are not a recommendation, offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Investing involves risk including loss of principal.
The books How to Change: The Science of Getting from Where You Are to Where You Want to Be, Level Up: Why Hierarchies Are Broken and How to Fix Them, Formula 1 Cars: The Greatest F1 Cars From 1950 to the Present Day, and Racing Legends are not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (CS&Co.). Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (CS&Co.) has not reviewed the books and makes no representations about their content.
1126-XRB0